Lyte,
Quite a collection indeed. I also owned the Gallo 3.1 - they do a lot of things right. Fast, coherent, well balanced. If I were you, I'd hang on to those at a minimum. (wish I had hung onto mine to use in a separate system, but so goes life). Your analogue gear is formidable. I don't have any direct expereince with that table or arm, and have really only played with that Shure cartridge for a few months about 15 years ago - although I do have warm memories... at least wrt whatever memories I can still remember at this stage in life. As for the various amplifiers, some very favorable gear there as well (I am especially fond of the Cary unit). Anyway, not sure if I can really offer any useful advice... other than what I try to live by: "Keep it simple" the shortest signal path you can manage, with the highest quality components should yield very, very good sound.
Cheers and good luck with your reassembly project.
-Todd